Biblical Inspiration … (September 2026 Update)
Some people love AI; others fear what it will do to human creativity and ingenuity. AI is becoming so good that it is often hard to tell if what has been produced is human or AI. Basically, AI largely eliminates the need for any human input or decision making.
When speaking about Biblical Inspiration, many people wrongly assume that biblical inspiration works a lot like AI. They think it means that God basically took over the human authors and wrote what He wanted without any human elements in their writings. This approach is often called the dictation method or the mechanical dictation theory. It asserts that God transmitted Scripture word-for-word to passive human writers, who acted merely as mechanical scribes, secretaries, or typewriters recording a divine message. This approach suggests that human writers contributed no personal style, emotion, or vocabulary; they functioned like stenographers or amanuenses (dictation scribes). Many think this is the evangelical approach to inspiration – but it is not. Even the early Reformers (like Luther and Calvin) rejected such ideas, though later Protestant scholastic scholars advocated it.
But the Bible itself testifies against such an approach to inspiration. The books of the Bible display clear personal vocabularies, grammar, and literary styles unique to individual authors (for example, the distinct Greek style of Luke versus Paul or Matthew). Also, writers like Luke explicitly mention gathering eyewitness accounts and doing their historical research (Luke 1:1–4) rather than simply taking passive dictation. For example, As J.I. Packer writes “that in inspiration God did not obliterate the personality, style, outlook, and cultural conditioning of his penmen…”. Likewise, Benjamin Warfield argues against proponents of dictation in illustrating the unlikely process of God dictating letters to Paul: “violently forcing the material He wished expressed through him”. Warfield concludes “nothing of the sort took place.”
(more…)



